Suffering Footprint is not the first attempt to compare foods by animal suffering. It stands on earlier work and should be judged against it.
| Tool | What it does | Main gap for everyday use |
|---|---|---|
| Brian Tomasik | Foundational per-kg model with lifespan, yield, sentience weight, daily suffering and slaughter.1 | Per kg only; Tomasik notes that per-calorie or per-protein would be better. No shrimp, insects or bivalves. |
| Comparing Suffering | Converts Tomasik's numbers to calories and protein, with brain-based weighting options.2 | Built on the older inputs; limited species and no current welfare-range model. |
| FoodImpacts | Farm hours per 2,000 kcal, optional welfare-range weighting, and a climate trade-off.3 | Focused on ranking species, not building a meal or exposing data to agents. |
| Faunalytics | Animal lives and days of suffering per kg, including feed fish, male chicks and price elasticity.4 | A research scale rather than an interactive, editable calculator. |
| Welfare Footprint calculator | Rigorous tool for cumulative pain from user-entered pain tracks, prevalence and productivity.5 | Designed for analysts who already have detailed inputs. |
| Animal welfare, visualized | Compares weighting methods and diet totals.6 | Exploratory article, not a reusable dataset or API. |
| AnimalVisuals | Animals killed per million calories, including estimated harvest deaths.7 | Counts deaths, not days or welfare intensity. |
| Counting Animals / The Vegan Calculator | Estimates animals spared by diet change.89 | Useful counts, but no species-by-species suffering footprint. |
What Suffering Footprint adds
- A per-animal ranking of capacity × conditions × time, consistent with the food footprint.
- One footprint, three fair comparisons: per kg, per 1,000 kcal and per 100 g protein.
- Three layers of evidence: animals, farmed days and welfare-weighted suffering-days.
- Current welfare-range inputs from Rethink Priorities, with proxies and editorial assumptions labelled.10
- Visible uncertainty: every footprint has a plausible range.
- Meal and diet calculations, not only single-food rankings.
- Agent-first access: open JSON data, an API and a remote MCP server.
What it still lacks
We do not yet model feed fish, breeder animals, male chicks, wild-animal effects or price elasticity. For those, Faunalytics and the Welfare Footprint Institute go further.45 We would rather say that clearly than claim a precision we do not have.
Sources
- Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
- Sandhoefner. "Comparing Suffering": animal suffering calculator per kg, calorie and gram of protein, built on Tomasik's figures. sandhoefner.github.io/animal_suffering_calculator
- FoodImpacts.org: ranks animal foods by farmed-animal suffering (farm hours per 2,000 kcal, optional welfare-range weighting) and climate impact. Methods page. foodimpacts.org/methods/
- Faunalytics. "Animal Product Impact Scales": animal lives and days of suffering per kg and per person, including feed fish, male chicks and price elasticity. faunalytics.org/animal-product-impact-scales/
- Welfare Footprint Institute. "Welfare impact calculator": combines user-entered Pain-Tracks, prevalence, mortality and productivity into cumulative pain per unit of product. welfarefootprint.org/tools/welfare-impact-calculator
- Stanley H. "Animal welfare, visualized": compares weighting schemes and whole-diet totals in life-days and suffering-days. www.henrystanley.com/weighing-animal-minds/
- AnimalVisuals. "The Number of Animals Killed to Produce One Million Calories in Eight Food Categories." animalvisuals.org/p/1mc
- Counting Animals: estimates of how many animals a person spares per year by changing diet. countinganimals.com/
- The Vegan Calculator: estimates animals, water, land and CO2 saved by eating vegan. thevegancalculator.com/
- Rethink Priorities. public_moral_weight_and_sentience (model code and summary statistics: "Priors Sentience Summary Statistics" and "WR Mixture Model – Summary Statistics"). GitHub. github.com/rethinkpriorities/public_moral_weight_and_sentience