Suffering Footprint

Which farmed animals suffer most? The suffering footprint of each food

Per animal first: capacity to suffer, conditions and time. Then count the lives, the days and the hours in pain behind each kilogram of food.

Updated 21 November 2026 · 19 sources cited

There are two honest ways to ask which farmed animals suffer most. Per animal: how much does one dairy cow, sow, hen or cricket suffer over its life? Per kilogram of food: how much suffering sits behind what we eat? The answers differ because a kilogram takes 0.015 of a pig but about 2,500 crickets. We lead with the first and then show the second.

Who suffers most, per animal

Per day = welfare range × P(sentience) × condition intensity; per animal = per day × days lived in those conditions. Breeding sows are included even though no food row counts them, because they live far longer in crates than the pigs raised for meat.123

Expected suffering per individual animal under current typical conditions, slaughter excluded (suffering-days per animal, central estimate with plausible range). Per day = welfare range × P(sentience) × condition intensity. est. = editorial estimate, not a published value. Plants and fungi score 0. Data: /api/hierarchy.
#Animal (system)P(sentience)Welfare rangeCondition intensityDaysPer dayPer animalBand
1Dairy cow0.8630.6240.5001,8250.269491162–1,470Band A
2Breeding sow breeding0.8640.6240.901 est.8160.486396131–1,190Band A
3Laying hen, battery cage0.8220.4441.005010.36518360.3–549Band A
4Laying hen, cage-free aviary0.8220.4440.3625010.13266.221.8–199Band A
5Meat pig, factory-farmed0.8640.6240.6251830.33761.720.3–185Band A
6Beef cattle0.8630.6240.2503950.13553.217.5–160Band A
7Turkey0.8220.4440.7501330.27436.412.0–109Band B
8Farmed catfish0.3100.3760.3758200.04435.87.17–179Band B
9Farmed salmon0.3110.2800.3756390.03320.94.17–104Band B
10Broiler chicken, fast-growing0.8220.4440.75042.00.27411.53.79–34.5Band B
11Broiler chicken, slower-growing0.8220.4440.25756.00.0945.251.73–15.8Band C
12Farmed shrimp (whiteleg)0.3110.1770.375 est.1500.0213.100.310–31.0Band C
13Farmed cricket0.3250.0950.375 est.52.00.0120.6020.060–6.02Band D
14Farmed oyster0.0500.0910.050 est.7300.000230.1660–3.32Band D
15Farmed mussel0.0500.0910.050 est.5480.000230.1250–2.49Band D

Per animal, dairy cows, crated breeding sows, caged hens and factory-farmed pigs score highest. Farmed shrimp, crickets and bivalves score lowest. The hierarchy of suffering adds lab animals and explains the bands.

1. The scale

Using FAO data for 2021, Our World in Data estimates that every day about 202 million chickens, 11.8 million ducks, 3.8 million pigs, 1.7 million sheep, 1.4 million goats and 900,000 cows are slaughtered for meat. That is about 74 billion chickens a year. These counts do not include male chicks killed in the egg industry.4 On top of that come roughly 124 billion farmed fish (2019),5 around 440 billion farmed shrimp6 and about a trillion farmed insects a year.7

2. Animals per kilogram

How many animals does one kilogram of food represent? The figures below divide one kilogram by the edible food produced per animal over its life.

FoodEdible food per animalAnimals per kgTypical life before slaughterSource
Beef212 kg0.005395 days2
Pork65 kg0.015183 days2
Turkey9.6 kg0.10133 days2
Chicken (broiler)1.9 kg0.5342 days2
Eggs (per hen, lifetime)16 kg0.06501 days2
Farmed salmon2.0 kg0.5639 days2
Farmed catfish0.39 kg2.6820 days2
Farmed shrimp~9 g (15.8 g live × 57% edible)~110~150 days68
Mussels9.74 g meat~10312–24 months910
Oysters11.77 g meat~8518–30 months911
Crickets (whole)0.35–0.45 g~2,5007–8 weeks127

In Andy Lamey's words, quoted by Tomasik, "one serving of chicken represents two hundred servings of beef" in terms of animals killed.2 Swapping beef for chicken, which many people do for health or climate reasons, multiplies the number of animals involved.

3. How bad is a farmed day? Hours in pain

The Welfare Footprint Project estimates how long farmed animals spend in four levels of pain (annoying, hurtful, disabling and excruciating) from the main welfare problems they face.1314

Animal and systemDisabling pain per animalHurtful pain per animalDisabling pain per kg of food
Broiler, conventional fast-growing50.27 h333.60 h26.5 h
Broiler, slower-growing (reformed)17.26 h255.70 h9.1 h
Laying hen, conventional cage431.86 h4,052.50 h27.0 h
Laying hen, furnished cage178.49 h3,488.59 h11.2 h
Laying hen, cage-free aviary156.42 h1,759.73 h9.8 h

Per-animal hours: Welfare Footprint Pain-Track.1516 Per-kg column = disabling hours ÷ edible kg per animal (1.9 kg per broiler, 16 kg of eggs per hen).2 This is our derivation, and it assumes reformed birds yield the same meat, which matches Welfare Footprint's assumption of the same 2.5 kg slaughter weight.13

Two findings stand out. For broilers, lameness causes the largest share of hurtful and disabling pain, and moving to slower-growing breeds prevents an estimated 66% of disabling pain.13 For hens, going from conventional cages to cage-free aviaries prevents about 275 hours of disabling pain per hen, mostly by relieving the frustration of being unable to nest, forage or move.1417 Welfare Footprint also found that chronic hunger in broiler breeder hens is "the greatest source of physical pain that any individual chicken" endures.13 Breeders are not counted in our per-kg figures at all.

4. Putting it together: the food footprint per kg

To compare foods, we combine four inputs into a single footprint, following the structure of Brian Tomasik's well-known analysis2 but using Rethink Priorities' sentience and welfare-range estimates:1

Formula: days of animal life per kilogram, times probability of sentience, times intensity, times how bad a farmed day is, equals the suffering index Days of lifeper kglifespan ÷ kg per animal × P(sentience)chance it can feelanything at all × Intensitywelfare rangeif sentient (human = 1) × Farm-daybadness0 = fine, 1 = worst = Indexper kg

Suffering footprint per kg (suffering-days) = (days of life per animal ÷ kg of food per animal) × P(sentience) × intensity if sentient × farm-day badness
= suffering per animal × animals per kg

  • Days of life per kg: lifespan before slaughter divided by edible yield (table above).
  • P(sentience): Rethink Priorities' prior probability of sentience (median). Where a species was not modelled, we borrow the nearest one and say so.1
  • Intensity if sentient: Rethink Priorities' welfare range from their mixture model (median, human = 1), before sentience adjustment.1
  • Farm-day badness (0–1): how much of that range an average farmed day uses up. Defaults are Tomasik's per-day suffering guesses scaled so that battery hens = 1. For cage-free eggs and slower-growing chickens we scale by Welfare Footprint's disabling-pain ratios. For shrimp, insects and bivalves no published value exists, so we mark our default as an editorial assumption.21615

The result is in suffering-days: roughly "human-equivalent days at the worst end of the welfare range" per kilogram. Treat it as a relative score, not a literal measurement. To compare foods fairly as nutrition, the calculator also converts every footprint to per 1,000 kcal and per 100 g of protein using USDA FoodData Central values, and shows a plausible range. The full method is on the method page.

Food footprint per kg (counts animals per kg). Default inputs and the resulting suffering footprint (suffering-days, central estimate, slaughter excluded). Per kg counts how many animals it takes: about 2,500 crickets vs 0.015 pigs per kg. Per animal, a cricket ranks near the bottom; see the last column and the per-animal ranking. * = editorial assumption, not a measured value. Change any of them in the calculator.
FoodAnimals per kgDays of life per kgP(sentience)Intensity if sentientFarm-day badnessSuffering-days per kgper 1,000 kcalper 100 g proteinPer animalFood footprint tier
Beans, grains, vegetables, fruit000000000Green
Mushrooms and other fungi000000000Green
Cow's milk0.0000330.0610.8630.6240.5000.0160.0270.052491Amber
Beef0.00471.860.8630.6240.2500.2510.1430.11853.2Amber
Pork0.0152.820.8640.6240.6250.9490.4390.49961.7Amber
Turkey0.10413.90.8220.4440.7503.793.301.6836.4Red
Chicken (fast-growing broiler)0.52622.10.8220.4440.7506.055.082.8311.5Red
Chicken (slower-growing, Better Chicken Commitment)0.52629.50.8220.4440.2572.762.321.295.25Red
Eggs (battery cages)0.06331.30.8220.4441.0011.47.999.07183Red
Eggs (cage-free aviary)0.06331.30.8220.4440.3624.142.893.2866.2Red
Farmed salmon0.5003200.3110.2800.37510.45.025.1120.9Red
Farmed catfish2.562,1030.3100.3760.37591.977.260.535.8Red
Farmed shrimp (whiteleg)11116,6670.3110.1770.375*3444051713.10Red
Farmed crickets (whole)2,500130,0000.3250.0950.375*1,5051,0757530.602Red
Farmed mussels10356,2630.0500.0910.050*12.814.910.80.125Provisional green
Farmed oysters85.062,0220.0500.0910.050*14.123.927.00.166Provisional green

5. What the per-kg numbers say

Per kg counts how many animals it takes: about 2,500 crickets vs 0.015 pigs per kg. Per animal, a cricket ranks near the bottom.

  1. Per kilogram, farmed insects, shrimp and small farmed fish dominate. Even with sentience probabilities around 0.3 and low intensity estimates, the number of lives per kilogram overwhelms the discount.
  2. Eggs, salmon and chicken are next. Eggs from caged hens score above chicken meat. Cage-free eggs cut the footprint by about 64% and slower-growing chickens by about 54%, but both remain well above pork and beef.
  3. Pork, beef and dairy are lowest among animal foods per kilogram. Not because cows and pigs suffer less (they are among the most sentient animals farmed), but because one animal produces so much food. This matches Tomasik's conclusion that farmed seafood causes the most direct suffering per kilogram, followed by eggs and poultry, with pork, beef and especially milk far lower.2
  4. Bivalves are the wild card. With our proxy assumptions they land near eggs and salmon. With a sentience probability under 1%, they fall below pork. See the oyster page.

What this analysis leaves out

  • Breeder animals, male chicks culled at hatch, calves in dairy, and animals that die before slaughter.24
  • Wild fish caught to feed farmed fish, pigs and poultry.25
  • The pain of slaughter itself, which Tomasik adds as extra "days". It is off by default here; switch it on in the calculator.2
  • Price elasticity: buying one kilogram less does not cut production by exactly one kilogram. Faunalytics models this; we do not.18
  • Environmental and wild-animal effects, which can point in different directions. Beef, for example, has a much bigger climate footprint.24

Want different assumptions? Change them in the calculator.

Quick answers

Which farmed animals suffer the most?

Per animal: dairy cows, crated breeding sows, caged hens and factory-farmed pigs. Per kilogram of food the order flips toward small animals (insects, shrimp, small fish), because a kilogram takes thousands of them.219

What is the most ethical meat?

Measured by suffering footprint, the lowest-suffering animal foods per kilogram are dairy, beef and pork, plus oysters and mussels if you accept that they are very unlikely to be sentient. The most ethical choice is still plants.

Are cage-free eggs better?

Yes. Welfare Footprint estimates cage-free aviaries prevent about 275 hours of disabling pain per hen compared with conventional cages.14 They still score above chicken, pork and beef per kilogram in our index. Per hen, cage-free cuts expected suffering from about 183 to 66 suffering-days.

Sources

  1. Rethink Priorities. public_moral_weight_and_sentience (model code and summary statistics: "Priors Sentience Summary Statistics" and "WR Mixture Model – Summary Statistics"). GitHub. github.com/rethinkpriorities/public_moral_weight_and_sentience
  2. Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
  3. Wurtz K, Schuck-Paim C. Welfare Footprint Project, "Pigs": the U.S. transition to group housing for gestating sows (stalls associated with high levels of stereotypic behaviour and gastric ulcers; about 58% of U.S. large-enterprise operations house gestating sows in stalls, USDA NAHMS Swine 2021–22). welfarefootprint.org/species/pigs
  4. Roser M (2023). "How many animals get slaughtered every day?" Our World in Data (FAO data for 2021). ourworldindata.org/how-many-animals-get-slaughtered-every-day
  5. fishcount.org.uk. "Fish count estimates" (wild-caught and farmed fish numbers; Mood & Brooke, Animal Welfare). fishcount.org.uk/fish-count-estimates-2
  6. Waldhorn DR, Autric E (2023). "Shrimp: The animals most commonly used and killed for food production." Rethink Priorities. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/shrimp-the-animals-most-commonly-use
  7. Rowe A (2020). "Insects raised for food and feed — global scale, practices, and policy." Rethink Priorities. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/insects-raised-for-food-and-feed/
  8. FAO (1989). "Yield and nutritional value of the commercially more important fish species." FAO Fisheries Technical Paper 309, Table 1 (edible yield: Penaeus shrimps 57%). www.fao.org/4/T0219E/T0219E01.htm
  9. Lake J (2013). "Validation of Commercial Shellfish Conversion Factor in RI." Rhode Island DEM, Division of Fish and Wildlife (blue mussel meat 9.74 g; eastern oyster meat 11.77 g per animal). dem.ri.gov/sites/g/files/xkgbur861/files/programs/bnatres/marine/pdf/Lak
  10. FAO Cultured Aquatic Species Information Programme: Mytilus edulis (blue mussel): 12–24 month growing cycles. www.fao.org/fishery/docs/DOCUMENT/aquaculture/CulturedSpecies/file/en/en
  11. FAO Cultured Aquatic Species Information Programme: Crassostrea gigas (Pacific cupped oyster): market size in 18–30 months. www.fao.org/fishery/docs/DOCUMENT/aquaculture/CulturedSpecies/file/en/en
  12. Farkas VI, Máté M, Takács K, Jánosi A (2025). "The House Cricket (Acheta domesticus Linnaeus) in Food Industry: Farming, Technological Challenges, and Sustainability Considerations." Applied Sciences 15(17):9494. www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/15/17/9494
  13. Welfare Footprint Project. "The impact of the Better Chicken Commitment and the use of slower-growing breeds on the welfare of broiler chickens at the farm level" (chapter 7). welfarefootprint.org/publications/broilers-ch07.pdf
  14. Welfare Footprint Project. "Transition to cage-free systems" (laying hens). welfarefootprint.org/species/laying-hens
  15. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: broilers (time in pain, conventional vs reformed/slower-growing). cp.pain-track.org/broilers
  16. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: laying hens (time in pain in conventional cages, furnished cages and aviaries). cp.pain-track.org/hens
  17. Our World in Data. "Do better cages or cage-free environments really improve the lives of hens?" ourworldindata.org/do-better-cages-or-cage-free-environments-really-impr
  18. Faunalytics. "Animal Product Impact Scales": animal lives and days of suffering per kg and per person, including feed fish, male chicks and price elasticity. faunalytics.org/animal-product-impact-scales/
  19. Fischer B (2023). "Rethink Priorities' Welfare Range Estimates." Rethink Priorities, Moral Weight Project. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/welfare-range-estimates/