Suffering Footprint

Method: how the suffering footprint is calculated

Both formulas (per animal and per kg), inputs, estimates, units, uncertainty and exclusions, in one place.

Updated 21 November 2026 · 24 sources cited

Formula 1: suffering per individual animal

per_day_intensity = welfare range × P(sentience) × condition intensity
per_individual_score (suffering-days per animal) = per_day_intensity × duration in days [+ slaughter-equivalent days]

This is the headline ranking on the home page and the hierarchy of suffering. It answers: “how much does one animal of this kind, in this system, suffer?”

  • condition_intensity (0–1): how bad an average day is under current typical conditions, as a share of the negative welfare range. It is the same number as farm-day badness below. You can change it per animal in the calculator; that is where an editorial choice about conditions belongs, documented, not hidden in other inputs.
  • duration_days: days the individual spends in those conditions.
  • Severity bands: A ≥ 50, B 10–50, C 1–10, D under 1 suffering-days per animal. They are separate from the five evidence tiers.
  • Estimates: where no published value exists, the value is our editorial estimate. It is marked est. on the site and listed in assume[] in the API. The breeding sow (condition intensity while crated; see breeding sows) and the lab macaque (all four inputs: there is no Rethink Priorities estimate for primates) rely most on estimates, and their plausible ranges are ÷3 to ×3 and ÷4 to ×4.123

Breeding sows

Tomasik's per-day figures exclude breeders, so this row is our estimate.4 We split a breeding sow's life into two phases, each with its own days and condition intensity, and add them up: score = Σ days × P(sentience) × welfare range × condition intensity. Sentience (0.864) and welfare range (0.624) are the pig values.5

Breeding sow inputs. est. = editorial estimate, not a published value.
PhaseDaysCondition intensityPer daySuffering-daysBasis
Gilt rearing (birth to first service)215 (200–225)0.6250.33772Age at first service 200–225 days in PIC's gilt guidelines;6 the factory-farmed meat-pig intensity from Tomasik.4
Breeding life in stalls and crates (first service to removal)601 (IQR 293–881)1.0 est.0.539324Median 601 days from first service to removal for culled sows, median parity 4 at culling (4 Midwest US farms, 2009–2018).7 PigCHAMP data: average removal parity 4.5 across 132 US farms, with fewer than half of sows reaching five litters;8 culls averaged parity 3.8 in 2001–2003.9
Whole life8160.901 (average)0.486 (average)396Plausible range ÷3 to ×3: about 130–1,190.

Why almost the whole breeding life counts as crated. One reproductive cycle is about 114 days of gestation, about 21 days of lactation and 5–7 days from weaning to the next service, about 140–145 days in total. Four parities is therefore about 570–580 days, which agrees with the 601-day median. In a US stall system a sow is in a gestation stall from breeding until about day 110, then in a farrowing crate from about five days before farrowing until weaning, then back in a breeding stall. We assume this for the whole breeding phase. It holds for stall-housed herds; about 58% of large US operations house gestating sows in stalls (USDA NAHMS Swine 2021–22).1

Why condition intensity 1.0 est. This is an analogy, not a measurement. A battery-caged hen is 1.0, the top of the scale. Welfare Footprint finds that most of a caged hen's disabling pain comes from frustration at being unable to nest, forage or move, and that moving hens to aviaries prevents about 275 hours of disabling pain per hen.10 A stalled sow faces the same kind of deprivation, or worse: she cannot turn around for about four months per pregnancy, and her nest-building is thwarted in the farrowing crate. Welfare Footprint's inventory for sows lists thwarted locomotion, foraging and social interaction, loss of agency, chronic hunger, gastric ulcers, lameness and skin injuries, and stalls are associated with "high levels of stereotypic behavior and gastric ulcers".1 Sow mortality is higher, and pigs produced per sow lower, in countries where gestation crates are the norm (US, Canada, Brazil) than in the EU, which limits crates to four weeks after insemination.1112 Welfare Footprint has not yet published cumulative-pain hours for sows. When it does, we will replace the 1.0 analogy with a ratio derived from those numbers.

Result and sensitivity. 215 × 0.337 + 601 × 0.539 ≈ 396 suffering-days (lifetime average 0.486 per day). Using the interquartile range for the breeding phase (293–881 days) gives 230–547. Per day while crated (0.539) she is the worst-off animal in the model, ahead of the lab macaque (0.399), the battery-caged hen (0.365) and the meat pig (0.337). Over a lifetime she ranks third, behind the longer-lived dairy cow and the estimate-heavy lab macaque.

Formula 2: the food footprint per kg

Formula: days of animal life per kilogram, times probability of sentience, times intensity, times how bad a farmed day is, equals the suffering index Days of lifeper kglifespan ÷ kg per animal × P(sentience)chance it can feelanything at all × Intensitywelfare rangeif sentient (human = 1) × Farm-daybadness0 = fine, 1 = worst = Indexper kg

Suffering-days per kg = (days lived per animal [+ slaughter-equivalent days] ÷ kg of edible food per animal) × P(sentience) × welfare range if sentient × farm-day badness

suffering-days per kg = per_individual_score × animals per kg (= per_individual_score ÷ kg of food per animal)

The two formulas use one dataset and stay consistent: per kg is per animal multiplied by how many animals a kilogram takes. Per kg counts how many animals it takes: about 2,500 crickets vs 0.015 pigs per kg. Per animal, a cricket ranks near the bottom. Per kg answers a different, real question: what does eating a kilogram of this cause?

This follows the structure of Brian Tomasik's per-kg analysis, updated with Rethink Priorities' sentience and welfare-range models and Welfare Footprint estimates for some production systems.451310

InputMeaningMain source
Days lived per animalAverage days from birth or hatching to slaughter or harvestTomasik; RP and FAO for shrimp; RI DEM and FAO for bivalves; published data for crickets4141516
Edible food per animalKilograms of meat, eggs or milk produced per animal over its lifeSame sources as lifespans
P(sentience)Probability that the animal has conscious experiences at allRethink Priorities, with labelled proxies5
Welfare rangeIntensity of possible experience relative to a human = 1, if sentientRethink Priorities mixture model517
Farm-day badnessShare of the negative welfare range used on an average farmed dayTomasik's estimates, adjusted with Welfare Footprint pain data; editorial assumptions where no estimate exists41013
Calories and proteinkcal and grams of protein per kg of raw edible foodUSDA FoodData Central; EFSA and composition data for crickets1819202122

Four normalisations

  • Per animal answers: “How much does one of these animals suffer?”
  • Per kg answers: “What if I buy a kilogram of this?”
  • Per 1,000 kcal answers: “What if I get the same energy from this food?” Milk is mostly water, so this matters.4
  • Per 100 g protein answers: “What if I use this food as my protein source?”

We use raw edible-weight nutrition values to match yields per animal. Cooked foods change weight, but not the number of animals behind them.

Three outputs

  • Animals: individual lives used.
  • Farmed days: days those animals lived on farms. This is the least judgement-laden number.
  • Suffering-days: farmed days weighted by sentience, welfare range and conditions. This is the headline footprint.

Uncertainty

Every central value is an estimate. We show a plausible range using editorial multipliers: ÷3 to ×3 for mammals and birds (÷4 to ×4 for the lab macaque, whose inputs are all estimates), ÷5 to ×5 for fish, ÷10 to ×10 for crustaceans and insects, and 0 to ×20 for bivalves. Wider bands mean less certainty about sentience, intensity or conditions. These ranges are not statistical confidence intervals. They are there to stop a single number looking more precise than it is.

Per kg, the ordering of the largest gaps is fairly robust: chicken, eggs and small farmed animals tend to have much larger footprints than beef or dairy because one large animal produces far more food. The position of bivalves is the most assumption-sensitive result.

What is excluded

  • Breeder animals, male chicks culled in egg production, calves in dairy and animals that die before slaughter.4
  • Wild fish caught for feed, wild animals affected by crops or grazing, and environmental effects.23
  • Price elasticity: when you buy less, production may not fall one-for-one. Faunalytics includes this in its scales.24
  • Positive experiences on farms. The footprint measures suffering, not net welfare.

Data and reuse

All inputs are available as JSON, the per-animal ranking as /api/hierarchy, and through the API and MCP server. Please cite the original sources as well as this site.

Sources

  1. Wurtz K, Schuck-Paim C. Welfare Footprint Project, "Pigs": the U.S. transition to group housing for gestating sows (stalls associated with high levels of stereotypic behaviour and gastric ulcers; about 58% of U.S. large-enterprise operations house gestating sows in stalls, USDA NAHMS Swine 2021–22). welfarefootprint.org/species/pigs
  2. Balcombe J (2014). "A Longitudinal View of Primate Life in Two American Laboratories." White paper (laboratory primates usually confined indoors to a metal cage, often alone). www.wellbeingintlstudiesrepository.org/acwp_arte/5
  3. USDA APHIS. Research Animal Use Summary, fiscal year 2025 (non-human primates: 31,641 used with no pain, 28,259 with pain relieved, 1,020 with pain not relieved, 45,510 held but not used). direct.aphis.usda.gov/sites/default/files/fy2025-research-animal-use-sum
  4. Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
  5. Rethink Priorities. public_moral_weight_and_sentience (model code and summary statistics: "Priors Sentience Summary Statistics" and "WR Mixture Model – Summary Statistics"). GitHub. github.com/rethinkpriorities/public_moral_weight_and_sentience
  6. PIC. "Breed Gilts at the Right Time and Weight" (gilt breeding eligibility: ideal age at breeding 200–225 days, 135–160 kg). www.pic.com/resources/breed-gilts-at-the-right-time-and-weight/
  7. Kikuti M, Preis GM, Deen J, Pinilla JC, Corzo CA (2023). "Sow mortality in a pig production system in the midwestern USA: Reasons for removal and factors associated with increased mortality." Veterinary Record 192(7): e2539 (four farrow-to-wean farms, PigCHAMP records 2009–2018; median 601 days from first service to removal for culled sows, IQR 293–881; median parity at culling 4). doi.org/10.1002/vetr.2539
  8. Engblom L, Stalder KJ, Mabry JW (2010). "Culling, Mortality and Lifetime Production among U.S. Sows." Iowa State University Animal Industry Report (PigCHAMP Datashare, 132 US farms: average removal parity 4.5; fewer than half of sows reach five litters). doi.org/10.31274/ans_air-180814-49
  9. Iowa State University Animal Science conference proceedings, item ans_conf/16 (PigCHAMP 2001–2003 records: culled sows averaged parity 3.8). dr.lib.iastate.edu/ans_conf/16
  10. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: laying hens (time in pain in conventional cages, furnished cages and aviaries). cp.pain-track.org/hens
  11. Schuck-Paim C, Alonso WJ (2022). "Productivity of mother pigs is lower in countries that still confine them in gestation crates." F1000Research 11:564 (sow mortality higher and pigs per sow per year lower where gestation crates are the norm: US, Canada, Brazil). f1000research.com/articles/11-564/v1
  12. Welfare Footprint Project (2022). "Sow productivity and mortality" (InterPig data, 17 countries). welfarefootprint.org/species/sows-productivity-mortality
  13. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: broilers (time in pain, conventional vs reformed/slower-growing). cp.pain-track.org/broilers
  14. Waldhorn DR, Autric E (2023). "Shrimp: The animals most commonly used and killed for food production." Rethink Priorities. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/shrimp-the-animals-most-commonly-use
  15. Lake J (2013). "Validation of Commercial Shellfish Conversion Factor in RI." Rhode Island DEM, Division of Fish and Wildlife (blue mussel meat 9.74 g; eastern oyster meat 11.77 g per animal). dem.ri.gov/sites/g/files/xkgbur861/files/programs/bnatres/marine/pdf/Lak
  16. Farkas VI, Máté M, Takács K, Jánosi A (2025). "The House Cricket (Acheta domesticus Linnaeus) in Food Industry: Farming, Technological Challenges, and Sustainability Considerations." Applied Sciences 15(17):9494. www.mdpi.com/2076-3417/15/17/9494
  17. Fischer B (2023). "Rethink Priorities' Welfare Range Estimates." Rethink Priorities, Moral Weight Project. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/welfare-range-estimates/
  18. USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy 171052: "Chicken, broilers or fryers, meat only, raw" (119 kcal, 21.4 g protein per 100 g). fdc.nal.usda.gov/food-details/171052/nutrients
  19. USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy 171287: "Egg, whole, raw, fresh" (143 kcal, 12.6 g protein per 100 g). fdc.nal.usda.gov/food-details/171287/nutrients
  20. USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy 175179: "Crustaceans, shrimp, raw" (85 kcal, 20.1 g protein per 100 g). fdc.nal.usda.gov/food-details/175179/nutrients
  21. EFSA NDA Panel (2024). "Safety of frozen, dried and powder forms of house crickets (Acheta domesticus) as a novel food." EFSA Journal 22:e9101 (frozen crickets: 19.7–20.9 g protein per 100 g). doi.org/10.2903/j.efsa.2024.9101
  22. All Things Bugs. "Nutritional Content of Insects and Other High Protein Foods" (house cricket, raw wet weight: about 140 kcal and 20.5 g protein per 100 g). allthingsbugs.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/AllThingsBugsNutrition.pdf
  23. Fischer B, Lamey A (2018). "Field Deaths in Plant Agriculture." Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 31:409–428. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10806-018-9733-8
  24. Faunalytics. "Animal Product Impact Scales": animal lives and days of suffering per kg and per person, including feed fish, male chicks and price elasticity. faunalytics.org/animal-product-impact-scales/