Suffering Footprint

Objections and FAQ

The strongest arguments against the suffering footprint and Painparity, and our best answers.

Updated 21 November 2026 · 8 sources cited

The suffering footprint makes strong claims on uncertain evidence, so it should face hard questions. Here are the ones we hear most, answered as fairly as we can.

Do animals feel pain?

Mammals and birds almost certainly do. The 2024 New York Declaration found strong scientific support for their conscious experience. For fish, cephalopods, decapod crustaceans and insects it found at least a realistic possibility.1

Isn't a "hierarchy" just speciesism with extra steps?

No. Speciesism means favouring interests because of species membership.2 Painparity counts equal suffering equally. The hierarchy only describes how likely and how intense suffering is, based on evidence that can change.

Why multiply by probability of sentience instead of just giving everyone the benefit of the doubt?

Giving every organism full weight would make bacteria and plants as important as pigs, which nobody believes. Ignoring uncertain animals entirely is how fish and invertebrates were overlooked for decades. Expected value is the honest middle path, and the New York Declaration says realistic possibilities should not be ignored.1

Aren't welfare-range numbers made up?

They are estimates built from more than 90 empirical traits and several models. Their authors call them "placeholders" with wide uncertainty.3 We use them because the alternative is unstated guesses. You can override them in the calculator.

Plants respond to damage. Why don't they count?

Responding to damage is not feeling it. Plants have no neurons, and plant scientists argue they neither possess nor need consciousness.4

Doesn't plant agriculture kill animals too?

Yes, though estimates are very uncertain and many deaths could be avoided.5 Livestock also eat crops, so plant-based diets generally use much less farmland.6

Your method says beef is better than chicken. Isn't that absurd?

Per kilogram, yes, it says that. One cow yields over 100 times as much meat as one chicken.7 Per animal it is the other way round: one beef cow scores about 53 suffering-days, one broiler about 11. Beef is much worse for the climate, and plants beat both.

Why are oysters "green" if you admit they might score like eggs?

Because the framework has an evidence gate. On current evidence bivalves are not sentience candidates.8 We show the arithmetic anyway, so you can disagree with the gate.

Is a fish's pain "less" than a dog's?

Not as a matter of worth. It may be less intense, and the evidence for it is less certain, so expected suffering per fish is lower.3 Equal pain counts equally.

What about humans? Does the footprint rank people?

Human suffering counts fully, and the framework gives no basis for ranking humans against each other. Rethink Priorities' researchers think the welfare ranges of humans and many vertebrates are within an order of magnitude of each other.3

What would change your mind?

New evidence, such as solid studies of pain-related trade-offs in bivalves, or evidence against sentience in insects. The tiers are meant to move with the science.

Who is behind this site?

SufferingFootprint.com is an independent site. It has no affiliation with the researchers or organisations cited. See sources and method.

Sources

  1. The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness (19 April 2024), New York University. sites.google.com/nyu.edu/nydeclaration/declaration
  2. Gruen L. "The Moral Status of Animals." Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (quotes Bentham 1789 and discusses Singer and speciesism). plato.stanford.edu/entries/moral-animal/
  3. Fischer B (2023). "Rethink Priorities' Welfare Range Estimates." Rethink Priorities, Moral Weight Project. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/welfare-range-estimates/
  4. Taiz L, Alkon D, Draguhn A, Murphy A, Blatt M, Hawes C, Thiel G, Robinson DG (2019). "Plants neither possess nor require consciousness." Trends in Plant Science 24(8):677–687. doi.org/10.1016/j.tplants.2019.05.008
  5. Fischer B, Lamey A (2018). "Field Deaths in Plant Agriculture." Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 31:409–428. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10806-018-9733-8
  6. Roser M (2023). "How many animals get slaughtered every day?" Our World in Data (FAO data for 2021). ourworldindata.org/how-many-animals-get-slaughtered-every-day
  7. Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
  8. Birch J (2024). "Pushing the Boundaries." Chapter in The Edge of Sentience (on gastropods as investigation priorities and bivalves). academic.oup.com/book/57949/chapter/475705076