The low-footprint diet aims to minimise your suffering footprint: expected suffering per kilogram, per calorie and per gram of protein. It is not a purity test. It ranks foods using two transparent steps, so you can see exactly why each food lands where it does, and where you might disagree.
Step 1: the evidence gate
Is the food made from a being for which there is a realistic possibility of sentience? We use the categories of the 2024 New York Declaration and Jonathan Birch's precautionary framework.12
- No realistic possibility (plants, fungi, algae) → Green.3
- Not currently a sentience candidate, evidence very thin (bivalves) → Provisional green for sessile oysters and mussels, and Amber for mobile scallops and clams.456
- Realistic possibility or stronger (all vertebrates, cephalopods, decapods, insects) → go to step 2.1
Step 2: food footprint per kilogram
For sentience candidates, we use the suffering footprint per kg with default inputs to set a food footprint tier. This is food advice, not a ranking of animals: for how much each animal suffers, see the per-animal ranking. The rule is simple:
- Index below 1 per kg → Amber (reduce).
- Index 1 or above → Red (avoid).
The threshold of 1 is a judgement call. It falls between pork (about 0.95) and turkey (about 3.8) under defaults, where there is a natural gap in the data. Animals we could not model (octopus, squid, crabs, lobsters, wild-caught fish) are red because of strong sentience evidence and, for wild fish, the huge numbers involved.78
The result: food footprint tiers
Per kg counts how many animals it takes: about 2,500 crickets vs 0.015 pigs per kg. Per animal, a cricket ranks near the bottom, and a dairy cow, a breeding sow or a caged hen near the top.
Green: eat freely
- Vegetables, fruit, grains, legumes, nuts, seeds
- Mushrooms and other fungi
- Seaweed and other algae
Provisional green: low risk, uncertain
- Farmed oysters
- Farmed mussels
- Farmed naked clams (shipworms), with a question mark: why
Green only because of the evidence gate. If you give them even a 5% chance of sentience, their per-kg index is similar to eggs.
Amber: reduce
- Dairy milk and cheese (footprint ≈ 0.02 per kg of milk)
- Beef (≈ 0.25)
- Pork (≈ 0.95)
- Scallops and clams (mobile bivalves, not modelled)
Red: avoid
- Farmed insects (≈ 1,500)
- Farmed shrimp (≈ 340)
- Farmed catfish and other small farmed fish (≈ 90)
- Eggs from caged hens (≈ 11), cage-free (≈ 4)
- Farmed salmon (≈ 10)
- Chicken (≈ 6; slower-growing ≈ 2.8)
- Turkey (≈ 3.8)
- Octopus, squid, crab, lobster, wild-caught fish (not modelled)
Practical priorities
- Replace chicken, eggs, fish and shrimp first. They account for most of the suffering per kilogram of food. Many people do the opposite, swapping red meat for chicken and fish.
- Do not switch to insect protein as an "ethical" meat. Each cricket scores low, but per kilogram, insect protein involves more animals than any food we model.
- If you eat some animal food, prefer large animals and dairy over small animals. Tomasik's practical advice for people who won't go vegan is to consider going lacto-vegetarian.9
- If you eat bivalves, choose rope-grown mussels and farmed oysters over scallops and dredged clams.6
- Mind your nutrients. People eating no animal products need a reliable vitamin B12 source.9
Where people disagree, honestly
- Vegans say oysters and mussels are animals and should not be eaten, whatever the evidence on pain.6 We follow the suffering evidence instead, but accepts that the precautionary argument has force.
- Climate and land. Beef scores low on direct suffering but has the largest climate footprint per calorie of the meats.9 The suffering footprint is about suffering. If you also care about climate, plants beat both beef and chicken.
- Animal rights views reject trading lives off against each other, so "beef is better than chicken" will sound wrong to them. The suffering footprint is explicitly an expected-suffering framework.
- Sceptics about invertebrate sentience would move shrimp and insects down. Try setting their P(sentience) close to zero in the calculator: chicken, eggs and fish still stay red.
- Wild-animal effects such as crop deaths and grazing land can shift results in either direction, and the estimates are very uncertain.10
Quick answers
Is it ethical to eat meat?
Under Painparity it depends on the suffering footprint of the specific food. Plants cause essentially none directly. Per kilogram of food, small farmed animals (chicken, eggs, fish, shrimp, insects) cause far more than beef, pork or dairy, because a kilogram takes many more animals. Per individual animal, dairy cows, breeding sows, caged hens and pigs suffer most.
What is an ostrovegan or bivalvegan?
Someone who eats a vegan diet plus some bivalves, typically oysters and mussels, on the grounds that these animals are very unlikely to feel pain. Peter Singer takes a similar view.6
Is the low-footprint diet vegan?
Almost. It differs on sessile bivalves, which are provisional green, and it ranks non-vegan foods by harm instead of treating them all as equally off-limits.
Sources
- The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness (19 April 2024), New York University. sites.google.com/nyu.edu/nydeclaration/declaration
- Birch J (2024). The Edge of Sentience: Risk and Precaution in Humans, Other Animals, and AI. Oxford University Press (open access). academic.oup.com/book/57949
- Taiz L, Alkon D, Draguhn A, Murphy A, Blatt M, Hawes C, Thiel G, Robinson DG (2019). "Plants neither possess nor require consciousness." Trends in Plant Science 24(8):677–687. doi.org/10.1016/j.tplants.2019.05.008
- Birch J (2024). "Pushing the Boundaries." Chapter in The Edge of Sentience (on gastropods as investigation priorities and bivalves). academic.oup.com/book/57949/chapter/475705076
- Aquaculture Advisory Council (2024). "Recommendation on Molluscan Welfare." aac-europe.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/1-AAC-Recommendation-on-Mollus
- Bryce E (12 Sep 2024). "'I'll have them with hot sauce': should vegans eat oysters?" The Guardian (interviews Peter Singer and Lynne Sneddon). www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/sep/12/ill-have-them-with-hot-sauce
- Birch J, Burn C, Schnell A, Browning H, Crump A (2021). "Review of the Evidence of Sentience in Cephalopod Molluscs and Decapod Crustaceans." LSE Consulting report for DEFRA. www.lse.ac.uk/business/consulting/reports/review-of-the-evidence-of-sent
- fishcount.org.uk. "Fish count estimates" (wild-caught and farmed fish numbers; Mood & Brooke, Animal Welfare). fishcount.org.uk/fish-count-estimates-2
- Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
- Fischer B, Lamey A (2018). "Field Deaths in Plant Agriculture." Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 31:409–428. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10806-018-9733-8