Suffering Footprint

The hierarchy of suffering: which animals suffer most?

Capacity to suffer × conditions × time, one animal at a time. Change any assumption and the ranking re-sorts.

Updated 21 November 2026 · 27 sources cited

The ranking: Per animal (lifetime)

Suffering-days per animal over its life: welfare range × P(sentience) × condition intensity × days.

Central estimate; the lighter band is the plausible range (log scale). est. = includes editorial estimates. Plants and fungi score 0. Not a ranking of moral worth. Select an animal for its inputs and sources.

Show as table
Per animal (lifetime): suffering-days per animal, central estimate and plausible range, slaughter excluded. est. = editorial estimate. Data: /api/hierarchy.
#Animal (system)P(sentience)Welfare rangeCondition intensityDaysPer animalRange
1Lab macaque research laboratory0.950 est.0.700 est.0.600 est.1,500 est.599150–2,394
2Dairy cow dairy, about 5 years in production0.8630.6240.5001,825491162–1,474
3Breeding sow stalls & crates0.8640.6240.901 est.816396131–1,189
4Laying hen, battery cage battery cage0.8220.4441.0050118360.3–549
5Laying hen, cage-free aviary cage-free aviary0.8220.4440.36250166.221.8–199
6Meat pig, factory-farmed indoor, slaughtered at about 6 months0.8640.6240.62518361.720.3–185
7Beef cattle beef0.8630.6240.25039553.217.5–160
8Turkey meat0.8220.4440.75013336.412.0–109
9Farmed catfish pond0.3100.3760.37582035.87.17–179
10Farmed salmon sea cage0.3110.2800.37563920.94.17–104
11Broiler chicken, fast-growing conventional broiler0.8220.4440.75042.011.53.79–34.5
12Broiler chicken, slower-growing Better Chicken Commitment0.8220.4440.25756.05.251.73–15.8
13Farmed shrimp (whiteleg) pond0.3110.1770.375 est.1503.100.310–31.0
14Farmed cricket insect farm0.3250.0950.375 est.52.00.6020.060–6.02
15Farmed oyster farmed0.0500.0910.050 est.7300.1660–3.32
16Farmed mussel rope culture0.0500.0910.050 est.5480.1250–2.49

Capacity × conditions × time

Which animal suffers most? Taking one animal at a time, we multiply what it can feel by how bad its days are and how many of them it lives through:

Per day = welfare range × P(sentience) × condition intensity
Per animal (suffering-days) = Σ over the phases of its life: per day × days in those conditions

  • Welfare range and P(sentience): Rethink Priorities' Moral Weight Project medians (human = 1). For cows and turkeys we borrow pigs and chickens; for the lab macaque no estimate exists, so we set ours just above pigs and label it.12
  • Condition intensity (0–1): how bad an average day is under current typical conditions. Tomasik's per-day estimates scaled so that a battery-caged hen = 1, adjusted with Welfare Footprint pain data for cage-free hens and slower-growing broilers.345
  • Days: how long the animal lives in those conditions, from birth or hatching to slaughter, or years in a lab. A breeding sow has two phases: about 215 days of rearing, then a median 601 days in stalls and farrowing crates.3678

Under these defaults a lab macaque, a dairy cow and a breeding sow in crates score highest. A dairy cow ranks high mainly because she lives about five years in production. Per day, the crated sow is first (0.539 while in stalls and crates), ahead of the macaque, with the caged hen third and the factory-farmed meat pig fourth. A meat pig lives only about six months, so it is sixth per lifetime. Lab macaques are confined indoors to a metal cage, often alone; in US fiscal year 2025, research facilities reported using 60,920 non-human primates.6910 Values marked est. are our editorial estimates where no published value exists. You can see them, question them and change them: select any animal in the ranking, or use Change the assumptions. The reasoning is on the method page.

Severity bands

  • Band A Severe: 50 or more suffering-days per animal: Lab macaque, Dairy cow, Breeding sow, Laying hen, battery cage, Laying hen, cage-free aviary, Meat pig, factory-farmed, Beef cattle
  • Band B 10 to 50 suffering-days per animal: Turkey, Farmed catfish, Farmed salmon, Broiler chicken, fast-growing
  • Band C 1 to 10 suffering-days per animal: Broiler chicken, slower-growing, Farmed shrimp (whiteleg)
  • Band D Under 1 suffering-day per animal: Farmed cricket, Farmed oyster, Farmed mussel

Bands describe expected suffering per animal. They are separate from the five evidence tiers below, which describe how strong the evidence for sentience is. Insects and bivalves are low per animal; they rank high per kilogram of food only because a kilogram takes hundreds or thousands of them (see the farmed animals page).

The evidence behind it

This page orders living things by two questions: how strong is the evidence that they can suffer, and how intense could that suffering be? It draws on four landmark documents and one large modelling project:

  • The Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness (2012) stated that "non-human animals, including all mammals and birds, and many other creatures, including octopuses" possess the neurological substrates that generate consciousness.11
  • The LSE report for the UK government (2021), led by Jonathan Birch, reviewed over 300 studies and recommended that all cephalopod molluscs and decapod crustaceans be regarded as sentient.12 Its findings led the UK to extend the Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 to them.1314
  • The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness (2024) found "strong scientific support" for conscious experience in mammals and birds, and "at least a realistic possibility" in all vertebrates and many invertebrates, including "at minimum, cephalopod mollusks, decapod crustaceans, and insects".15
  • Jonathan Birch's The Edge of Sentience (2024) sets out a precautionary framework that separates "sentience candidates", which deserve protection, from "investigation priorities", which need more research.1617
  • Rethink Priorities' Moral Weight Project estimated welfare ranges for 11 farmed species, meaning how intense their pleasures and pains can be relative to humans, adjusted for the probability that they are sentient at all.2

The five tiers

Evidence tiers and how intense experiences can be. Rethink Priorities’ sentience-adjusted welfare ranges (human = 1): dot = median, line = 5th to 95th percentile (log scale; an open left end means the 5th percentile is 0).2
  1. Tier 1 strong evidence

    1. Pigs0.5150.005–1.031
    2. Chickens0.3320.002–0.869
  2. Tier 2 realistic possibility, substantial evidence

    1. Octopuses0.2130.004–1.471
    2. Carp0.0890–0.568
    3. Salmon0.0560–0.513
    4. Crayfish0.0380–0.491
    5. Shrimp0.0310–1.149
    6. Crabs0.0230–0.414
  3. Tier 3 realistic possibility, growing evidence

    1. Bees0.0710–0.461
    2. Black soldier flies0.0130–0.196
    3. Silkworms0.0020–0.073
  4. Tier 4 unknown, investigation needed

    Bivalves (oysters, mussels): no welfare-range estimate exists; investigation needed.

  5. Tier 5 no realistic possibility

    Plants, fungi, algae: about 0; no neurons.

Tier 1: strong evidence. Mammals and birds

Including great apes, pigs, cows, dogs, chickens, turkeys and ducks. Both the 2012 and 2024 declarations treat their conscious experience as strongly supported.1115 Rethink Priorities' median welfare ranges are 0.515 for pigs and 0.332 for chickens, relative to humans at 1.2 Their researchers think it likely (credence 0.65) that humans and the vertebrates they studied have welfare ranges within an order of magnitude of each other.2

Tier 2: realistic possibility, substantial evidence. Fish, cephalopods, decapod crustaceans

Fish (and reptiles and amphibians) are vertebrates with nociceptors and flexible, learned responses to injury.1819 See: do fish feel pain? Octopuses, squid and cuttlefish, and crabs, lobsters, crayfish and shrimp were judged sentient enough to be covered by UK law.1214 Octopus and squid · Lobsters, crabs and shrimp. Median welfare ranges: octopus 0.213, carp 0.089, salmon 0.056, crayfish 0.038, shrimp 0.031, crabs 0.023.2

Tier 3: realistic possibility, growing evidence. Insects

A 2022 review of the neural and behavioural evidence found signs consistent with pain in several insect orders, and the New York Declaration names insects explicitly.2015 Bumblebees even seem to play.21 Median welfare ranges: bees 0.071, black soldier flies 0.013, silkworms 0.002.2 See: do insects feel pain?

Tier 4: unknown, investigation needed. Bivalves (and gastropods)

Oysters, mussels, clams, scallops and shipworms ("naked clams") have no brain, only a few ganglia (clusters of nerve cells).22 Birch treats gastropods (snails and slugs) as investigation priorities and puts bivalves "much further away" from a sufficient case for sentience.23 An EU aquaculture advisory body concluded in 2024 that it is not known whether bivalves are sentient, because there is so little evidence either way.22 Within bivalves, sessile species (oysters, mussels) fixed in place are generally considered less likely candidates than mobile ones, such as scallops, which swim and can sense movement and light.2425 See: do oysters and mussels feel pain?

Tier 5: no realistic possibility on current evidence. Plants, fungi, algae

They respond to damage, but have no neurons, and plant scientists argue they neither possess nor need consciousness.26 One Rethink Priorities researcher put plant consciousness at approximately 0%.27 See: do plants feel pain?

How intense can their experiences be? Welfare ranges

A welfare range is the gap between the best and worst experiences an animal can have. Rethink Priorities estimated these by reviewing more than 90 traits, such as learning, play, emotional responses and pain behaviour, across 11 farmed species, combining several models and adjusting for the probability that each animal is sentient.2 The numbers are deliberately framed as "placeholders": the best available, but highly uncertain.2

Rethink Priorities' sentience-adjusted welfare ranges, relative to humans = 1 (the data behind the chart above). These estimate how intense an animal's experiences can be, not how much the animal "matters".
Species5th percentileMedian95th percentile
Pigs0.0050.5151.031
Chickens0.0020.3320.869
Octopuses0.0040.2131.471
Carp00.0890.568
Bees00.0710.461
Salmon00.0560.513
Crayfish00.0380.491
Shrimp00.0311.149
Crabs00.0230.414
Black soldier flies00.0130.196
Silkworms00.0020.073

Two things are easy to miss. First, the uncertainty is huge. Shrimp's 90% interval runs from 0 to 1.149, wider than any vertebrate's.2 Second, a low welfare range is not a low moral status. In Painparity terms, if a shrimp and a pig suffer the same amount, it matters equally. The welfare range only estimates how much suffering is possible for each.

Probability of sentience

Rethink Priorities also modelled the probability that each animal is sentient at all. Their prior estimates (medians) are about 0.86 for pigs and cows, 0.82 for chickens, 0.73 for octopuses, around 0.31 for salmon, carp, crabs and crayfish, 0.41 for bees, 0.33 for black soldier flies, and about 0.05 for silkworms, earthworms and sea hares.1 These numbers feed our calculator, together with the welfare-range medians before sentience adjustment.

Why use probabilities at all? Because both extremes are wrong. Treating every uncertain animal as definitely sentient overstates what we know. Treating every uncertain animal as definitely not sentient is how invertebrates were ignored for decades. Birch's point is that a "realistic possibility" is enough to call for proportionate precaution.1615

What the hierarchy leaves out

  • Variation within groups. "Insects" covers a million described species. The tiers are rough.
  • Individual differences. A sick or frightened animal may suffer far more than a healthy one of the same species. The per-animal ranking above uses an average day under typical conditions.
  • Positive experiences. The suffering footprint focuses on suffering, but a welfare range covers pleasure too.

Quick answers

Which animals are sentient?

The New York Declaration (2024) found strong support for mammals and birds and a realistic possibility for all vertebrates (including fish) and many invertebrates, at minimum cephalopods, decapod crustaceans and insects.15

Which animal suffers the most?

Per individual, a lab primate, a dairy cow and a crated breeding sow score highest under our defaults, followed by caged hens and factory-farmed pigs. Insects and bivalves score lowest per animal.1310

Is there a hierarchy of suffering among animals?

In capacity, probably yes. Evidence and estimated intensity differ between groups. In moral worth, Painparity says no: equal suffering counts equally.

Sources

  1. Rethink Priorities. public_moral_weight_and_sentience (model code and summary statistics: "Priors Sentience Summary Statistics" and "WR Mixture Model – Summary Statistics"). GitHub. github.com/rethinkpriorities/public_moral_weight_and_sentience
  2. Fischer B (2023). "Rethink Priorities' Welfare Range Estimates." Rethink Priorities, Moral Weight Project. rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/welfare-range-estimates/
  3. Tomasik B (2007, last updated 2018). "How Much Direct Suffering Is Caused by Various Animal Foods?" Essays on Reducing Suffering (lifespans, edible yield per animal and per-day suffering guesses). reducing-suffering.org/how-much-direct-suffering-is-caused-by-various-an
  4. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: laying hens (time in pain in conventional cages, furnished cages and aviaries). cp.pain-track.org/hens
  5. Welfare Footprint Project, Pain-Track: broilers (time in pain, conventional vs reformed/slower-growing). cp.pain-track.org/broilers
  6. Balcombe J (2014). "A Longitudinal View of Primate Life in Two American Laboratories." White paper (laboratory primates usually confined indoors to a metal cage, often alone). www.wellbeingintlstudiesrepository.org/acwp_arte/5
  7. PIC. "Breed Gilts at the Right Time and Weight" (gilt breeding eligibility: ideal age at breeding 200–225 days, 135–160 kg). www.pic.com/resources/breed-gilts-at-the-right-time-and-weight/
  8. Kikuti M, Preis GM, Deen J, Pinilla JC, Corzo CA (2023). "Sow mortality in a pig production system in the midwestern USA: Reasons for removal and factors associated with increased mortality." Veterinary Record 192(7): e2539 (four farrow-to-wean farms, PigCHAMP records 2009–2018; median 601 days from first service to removal for culled sows, IQR 293–881; median parity at culling 4). doi.org/10.1002/vetr.2539
  9. USDA APHIS. Research Animal Use Summary, fiscal year 2025 (non-human primates: 31,641 used with no pain, 28,259 with pain relieved, 1,020 with pain not relieved, 45,510 held but not used). direct.aphis.usda.gov/sites/default/files/fy2025-research-animal-use-sum
  10. Wurtz K, Schuck-Paim C. Welfare Footprint Project, "Pigs": the U.S. transition to group housing for gestating sows (stalls associated with high levels of stereotypic behaviour and gastric ulcers; about 58% of U.S. large-enterprise operations house gestating sows in stalls, USDA NAHMS Swine 2021–22). welfarefootprint.org/species/pigs
  11. Low P, et al. (7 July 2012). "The Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness." Francis Crick Memorial Conference, Cambridge. fcmconference.org/img/CambridgeDeclarationOnConsciousness.pdf
  12. Birch J, Burn C, Schnell A, Browning H, Crump A (2021). "Review of the Evidence of Sentience in Cephalopod Molluscs and Decapod Crustaceans." LSE Consulting report for DEFRA. www.lse.ac.uk/business/consulting/reports/review-of-the-evidence-of-sent
  13. GOV.UK (19 Nov 2021). "Lobsters, octopus and crabs recognised as sentient beings." www.gov.uk/government/news/lobsters-octopus-and-crabs-recognised-as-sent
  14. Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022, section 5 ("animal" includes any vertebrate other than homo sapiens, any cephalopod mollusc and any decapod crustacean). legislation.gov.uk. www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/22/section/5
  15. The New York Declaration on Animal Consciousness (19 April 2024), New York University. sites.google.com/nyu.edu/nydeclaration/declaration
  16. Birch J (2024). The Edge of Sentience: Risk and Precaution in Humans, Other Animals, and AI. Oxford University Press (open access). academic.oup.com/book/57949
  17. The Edge of Sentience (book website, free PDF and summary). sites.google.com/view/edgeofsentience/home
  18. Sneddon LU, Braithwaite VA, Gentle MJ (2003). "Do fishes have nociceptors? Evidence for the evolution of a vertebrate sensory system." Proceedings of the Royal Society B 270:1115–1121. doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2003.2349
  19. Brown C (2015). "Fish intelligence, sentience and ethics." Animal Cognition 18:1–17. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10071-014-0761-0
  20. Gibbons M, Crump A, Barrett M, Sarlak S, Birch J, Chittka L (2022). "Can insects feel pain? A review of the neural and behavioural evidence." Advances in Insect Physiology 63:155–229. doi.org/10.1016/bs.aiip.2022.10.001
  21. Dona HSG, Solvi C, Kowalewska A, Mäkelä K, MaBouDi H, Chittka L (2022). "Do bumble bees play?" Animal Behaviour 194:239–251. doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2022.08.013
  22. Aquaculture Advisory Council (2024). "Recommendation on Molluscan Welfare." aac-europe.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/1-AAC-Recommendation-on-Mollus
  23. Birch J (2024). "Pushing the Boundaries." Chapter in The Edge of Sentience (on gastropods as investigation priorities and bivalves). academic.oup.com/book/57949/chapter/475705076
  24. Bryce E (12 Sep 2024). "'I'll have them with hot sauce': should vegans eat oysters?" The Guardian (interviews Peter Singer and Lynne Sneddon). www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/sep/12/ill-have-them-with-hot-sauce
  25. Animal Ethics (22 Jun 2021). "Snails and bivalves: a discussion of indicators of sentience." www.animal-ethics.org/snails-and-bivalves-a-discussion-of-possible-edge-
  26. Taiz L, Alkon D, Draguhn A, Murphy A, Blatt M, Hawes C, Thiel G, Robinson DG (2019). "Plants neither possess nor require consciousness." Trends in Plant Science 24(8):677–687. doi.org/10.1016/j.tplants.2019.05.008
  27. Rethink Priorities (2019). "Opinion: estimating invertebrate sentience." rethinkpriorities.org/research-area/opinion-estimating-invertebrate-sent